Carbike360 comprehensive MG Comet EV Executive and Tata Punch EV Smart 3.3 comparison based on the price, specification, fuel efficiency, features and more.
MG Comet EV Executive comes with a price of ₹ 7.00 Lakh and Tata Punch EV Smart 3.3 is priced at ₹ 9.99 Lakh. MG Comet EV Executive equipped with engine whereas Tata Punch EV Smart 3.3 has .
Ad
Mg Comet Ev Vs Tata Punch Ev
Select Car| Ex-Showroom Price | ₹7.00 Lakh | ₹9.99 Lakh | ||
| EMI | ₹12,922 /month 8.5% for 5 years Calculate EMI | ₹18,446 /month 8.5% for 5 years Calculate EMI | ||
| Brochure | Download Brochure | Download Brochure | ||
| User Rating | 4.1 | 4.0 | ||
| Colors |
Ex-Showroom Price
₹7.00 Lakh
₹9.99 Lakh
EMI
₹12,922 /month
8.5% for 5 years
Calculate EMI₹18,446 /month
8.5% for 5 years
Calculate EMIBrochure
User Rating
4.1
4.0
Colors
| Width(mm) | 1505 | 1742 | ||
| Kerb Weight(kg) | - | - | ||
| Ground Clearance(mm) | 165 | 190 | ||
| Length(mm) | 2974 | 3857 | ||
| Height(mm) | 1640 | 1633 | ||
| Wheelbase(mm) | 2010 | 2445 |
Width (mm)
1505
1742
Kerb Weight (kg)
-
-
Ground Clearance (mm)
165
190
Length (mm)
2974
3857
Height (mm)
1640
1633
Wheelbase (mm)
2010
2445
| Bootspace(litres) | - | 366 | ||
| Doors(Doors) | 3 | 5 | ||
| Seating Capacity(Person) | 4 | 5 | ||
| Fuel Tank Capacity(litres) | - | - | ||
| No of Rows(Rows) | 2 | 2 |
Bootspace (litres)
-
366
Doors (Doors)
3
5
Seating Capacity (Person)
4
5
Fuel Tank Capacity (litres)
-
-
No of Rows (Rows)
2
2
| Highway Mileage(kmpl) | - | - | ||
| Max Motor Performance | 41 bhp, 110 Nm | 80 bhp, 114 Nm | ||
| Turbocharger / Supercharger | Not Applicable | |||
| Range(km) | - | - | ||
| Engine Type | - | - | ||
| Top Speed(kmph) | - | - | ||
| Fuel Type | Electric | Electric | ||
| Transmission | Automatic - 1 Gears, Sport Mode | Automatic - 1 Gears | ||
| AC Fast Charging | 10-100 % : 3 hrs 36 mins, 7.2 kW charger | |||
| Emission Standard | Not Applicable | Not Applicable | ||
| Driving Range(km) | 230 | 315 | ||
| DC Fast Charging | 10-80 % : 56 mins, 50 kW charger | |||
| AC Regular Charging | 10-100 % : 9 hrs 24 mins, 15 A plug point | |||
| Battery Charging | - | - | ||
| Alternate Fuel | Not Applicable | Not Applicable | ||
| Electric Motor Assist | - | - | ||
| City Mileage(kmpl) | - | - | ||
| Performance on Alternate Fuel | - | - | ||
| Max Power (bhp@rpm) | - | - | ||
| Others | Regenerative Braking | Regenerative Braking, Pure Electric Driving Mode | ||
| Mileage (ARAI)(kmpl) | - | - | ||
| Electric Motor | 1 Permanent magnet synchronous Placed At Rear Axle | 1 Permanent magnet synchronous Placed At Front Axle | ||
| Engine | Not Applicable Cylinders Not Applicable, Not Applicable Valves/Cylinder, Not Applicable | - | ||
| Battery | 17.3 kWh, Lithium Ion,Battery Placed Under Front Seats | 25 kWh, Lithium Ion,Battery Placed Under Floor Pan | ||
| Max Torque (Nm@rpm) | - | - | ||
| Drivetrain | RWD | FWD | ||
| Acceleration (0-100 kmph)(seconds) | 19.97 | 13.5 |
Highway Mileage (kmpl)
-
-
Max Motor Performance
41 bhp, 110 Nm
80 bhp, 114 Nm
Turbocharger / Supercharger
Not Applicable
Range (km)
-
-
Engine Type
-
-
Top Speed (kmph)
-
-
Fuel Type
Electric
Electric
Transmission
Automatic - 1 Gears, Sport Mode
Automatic - 1 Gears
AC Fast Charging
10-100 % : 3 hrs 36 mins, 7.2 kW charger
Emission Standard
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
Driving Range (km)
230
315
DC Fast Charging
10-80 % : 56 mins, 50 kW charger
AC Regular Charging
10-100 % : 9 hrs 24 mins, 15 A plug point
Battery Charging
-
-
Alternate Fuel
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
Electric Motor Assist
-
-
City Mileage (kmpl)
-
-
Performance on Alternate Fuel
-
-
Max Power (bhp@rpm)
-
-
Others
Regenerative Braking
Regenerative Braking, Pure Electric Driving Mode
Mileage (ARAI) (kmpl)
-
-
Electric Motor
1 Permanent magnet synchronous Placed At Rear Axle
1 Permanent magnet synchronous Placed At Front Axle
Engine
Not Applicable Cylinders Not Applicable, Not Applicable Valves/Cylinder, Not Applicable
-
Battery
17.3 kWh, Lithium Ion,Battery Placed Under Front Seats
25 kWh, Lithium Ion,Battery Placed Under Floor Pan
Max Torque (Nm@rpm)
-
-
Drivetrain
RWD
FWD
Acceleration (0-100 kmph) (seconds)
19.97
13.5
| Wheels | Steel Rims | Steel Rims | ||
| Rear Suspension | Multi-Link Coil Suspension | Semi-independent Twist Beam With Coil Spring And Shock Absorber | ||
| Front Brake Type | Disc | Disc | ||
| Rear Brake Type | Drum | Drum | ||
| Steering Type | Power assisted (Electric) | Power assisted (Electric) | ||
| Four Wheel Steering | - | - | ||
| Spare Wheel | Steel | |||
| Front Tyres | 145 / 70 R12 | 185 / 70 R15 | ||
| Front Suspension | McPherson Strut | Independent, Lower Wishbone, McPherson Strut with Coil Spring | ||
| Rear Tyres | 145 / 70 R12 | 185 / 70 R15 | ||
| Minimum Turning Radius(metres) | 4.2 | 5 |
Wheels
Steel Rims
Steel Rims
Rear Suspension
Multi-Link Coil Suspension
Semi-independent Twist Beam With Coil Spring And Shock Absorber
Front Brake Type
Disc
Disc
Rear Brake Type
Drum
Drum
Steering Type
Power assisted (Electric)
Power assisted (Electric)
Four Wheel Steering
-
-
Spare Wheel
Steel
Front Tyres
145 / 70 R12
185 / 70 R15
Front Suspension
McPherson Strut
Independent, Lower Wishbone, McPherson Strut with Coil Spring
Rear Tyres
145 / 70 R12
185 / 70 R15
Minimum Turning Radius (metres)
4.2
5
| Cup Holders | Front Only | Front Only | ||
| Driver Armrest Storage | ||||
| Cooled Glovebox | ||||
| Sunglass Holder |
Cup Holders
Front Only
Front Only
Driver Armrest Storage
Cooled Glovebox
Sunglass Holder
| Turn Indicators on ORVMs | ||||
| Rain-sensing Wipers | ||||
| Interior Door Handles | Chrome | Black | ||
| Adjustable ORVMs | Electrically Adjustable | Internally Adjustable | ||
| Scuff Plates | ||||
| Exterior Door Handles | Chrome | Black | ||
| Door Pockets | Front | Front & Rear | ||
| Rear Defogger | ||||
| ORVM Colour | Body Coloured | Black | ||
| Power Windows | Front Only | Front Only | ||
| Rear Wiper | ||||
| One Touch Down | ||||
| One Touch Up | ||||
| Bootlid Opener | Remote Operated | Electric Tailgate Release |
Turn Indicators on ORVMs
Rain-sensing Wipers
Interior Door Handles
Chrome
Black
Adjustable ORVMs
Electrically Adjustable
Internally Adjustable
Scuff Plates
Exterior Door Handles
Chrome
Black
Door Pockets
Front
Front & Rear
Rear Defogger
ORVM Colour
Body Coloured
Black
Power Windows
Front Only
Front Only
Rear Wiper
One Touch Down
One Touch Up
Bootlid Opener
Remote Operated
Electric Tailgate Release
| Warranty (In Kilometres) | Not Applicable | 125000 | ||
| Battery Warranty (In Kilometres) | 120000 | 160000 | ||
| Warranty (In Years) | 3 | |||
| Battery Warranty (In Years) | 8 | 8 |
Warranty (In Kilometres)
Not Applicable
125000
Battery Warranty (In Kilometres)
120000
160000
Warranty (In Years)
3
Battery Warranty (In Years)
8
8
| Body-coloured Bumpers | ||||
| Sunroof / Moonroof | ||||
| Chrome Finish Exhaust Pipe | ||||
| Body Kit | Cladding - Black/Grey | |||
| Roof-mounted Antenna |
Body-coloured Bumpers
Sunroof / Moonroof
Chrome Finish Exhaust Pipe
Body Kit
Cladding - Black/Grey
Roof-mounted Antenna
| Rear Passenger Seat Type | Bench | Bench | ||
| Front Passenger Seat Adjustment | 4 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back) | 6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down) | ||
| Seat Upholstery | Fabric | Fabric | ||
| Leather-wrapped Steering Wheel | ||||
| Split Rear Seat | 50:50 split | |||
| Leather-wrapped Gear Knob | ||||
| Ventilated Seats | ||||
| Driver Seat Adjustment | 4 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back) | 8 way manually adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, headrest: up / down, seat height: up / down) | ||
| Interior Colours | Starlight Black | Black / White | ||
| Folding Rear Seat | Full | Full | ||
| Front Seatback Pockets | ||||
| Driver Armrest | ||||
| Headrests | Front & Rear | Front & Rear | ||
| Ventilated Seat Type | ||||
| Interiors | Single Tone | Dual Tone | ||
| Rear Row Seat Adjustment | - | 2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down) |
Rear Passenger Seat Type
Bench
Bench
Front Passenger Seat Adjustment
4 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back)
6 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back, headrest up / down)
Seat Upholstery
Fabric
Fabric
Leather-wrapped Steering Wheel
Split Rear Seat
50:50 split
Leather-wrapped Gear Knob
Ventilated Seats
Driver Seat Adjustment
4 way manually adjustable (seat forward / back, backrest tilt forward / back)
8 way manually adjustable (seat: forward / back, backrest tilt: forward / back, headrest: up / down, seat height: up / down)
Interior Colours
Starlight Black
Black / White
Folding Rear Seat
Full
Full
Front Seatback Pockets
Driver Armrest
Headrests
Front & Rear
Front & Rear
Ventilated Seat Type
Interiors
Single Tone
Dual Tone
Rear Row Seat Adjustment
-
2 way manually adjustable (headrest: up / down)
| Steering-mounted controls | ||||
| AUX Compatibility | ||||
| Apple CarPlay | ||||
| Android Auto | ||||
| iPod Compatibility | ||||
| USB Compatibility | ||||
| Smart Connectivity | Android Auto (No), Apple Car Play (No) | Android Auto (No), Apple Car Play (No) | ||
| Integrated (in-dash) Music System | ||||
| Display | ||||
| Speakers | 2 | |||
| Wireless Charger | ||||
| Head Unit Size | Not Applicable | Not Available | ||
| Bluetooth Compatibility | Phone & Audio Streaming | |||
| Voice Command | ||||
| GPS Navigation System | ||||
| AM/FM Radio | ||||
| Touchscreen Size(inch) | - | - |
Steering-mounted controls
AUX Compatibility
Apple CarPlay
Android Auto
iPod Compatibility
USB Compatibility
Smart Connectivity
Android Auto (No), Apple Car Play (No)
Android Auto (No), Apple Car Play (No)
Integrated (in-dash) Music System
Display
Speakers
2
Wireless Charger
Head Unit Size
Not Applicable
Not Available
Bluetooth Compatibility
Phone & Audio Streaming
Voice Command
GPS Navigation System
AM/FM Radio
Touchscreen Size (inch)
-
-
| Automatic Headlamps | ||||
| Puddle Lamps | ||||
| Taillights | Halogen | Halogen | ||
| Headlights | Halogen | LED | ||
| Follow Me Home Headlamps | ||||
| Ambient Interior Lighting | ||||
| Glovebox Lamp | ||||
| Daytime Running Lights | Halogen | Not Sure | ||
| Headlight Height Adjuster | ||||
| Fog Lights | LED | - | ||
| Cabin Lamps | Front | Front |
Automatic Headlamps
Puddle Lamps
Taillights
Halogen
Halogen
Headlights
Halogen
LED
Follow Me Home Headlamps
Ambient Interior Lighting
Glovebox Lamp
Daytime Running Lights
Halogen
Not Sure
Headlight Height Adjuster
Fog Lights
LED
-
Cabin Lamps
Front
Front
| Tachometer | ||||
| Instrument Cluster | Digital | Digital | ||
| Shift Indicator | Not Applicable | Not Applicable | ||
| Clock | Digital | Digital | ||
| Low Fuel Level Warning | ||||
| Heads Up Display (HUD) | ||||
| Gear Indicator | ||||
| Door Ajar Warning | ||||
| Instantaneous Consumption | ||||
| Adjustable Cluster Brightness | - | |||
| Distance to Empty | ||||
| Average Fuel Consumption | ||||
| Average Speed | - | |||
| Trip Meter | - | Electronic 2 Trips |
Tachometer
Instrument Cluster
Digital
Digital
Shift Indicator
Not Applicable
Not Applicable
Clock
Digital
Digital
Low Fuel Level Warning
Heads Up Display (HUD)
Gear Indicator
Door Ajar Warning
Instantaneous Consumption
Adjustable Cluster Brightness
-
Distance to Empty
Average Fuel Consumption
Average Speed
-
Trip Meter
-
Electronic 2 Trips
| Heater | ||||
| Cabin Boot Access | ||||
| Headlight and Ignition On Reminder | - | |||
| Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors | ||||
| Parking Sensors | Rear | Rear | ||
| Cruise Control | ||||
| Front AC | Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control | Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control | ||
| Keyless Start/ Button Start | ||||
| 12V Power Outlets | ||||
| Air Purifier | ||||
| Electronic Parking Brake | ||||
| Air Conditioner | Yes (Manual) | Yes (Automatic Climate Control) | ||
| Parking Assist | ||||
| Steering Adjustment | Tilt | |||
| Anti-glare Mirrors | Manual - Internal Only |
Heater
Cabin Boot Access
Headlight and Ignition On Reminder
-
Vanity Mirrors on Sun Visors
Parking Sensors
Rear
Rear
Cruise Control
Front AC
Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control
Single Zone, Common Fan Speed Control
Keyless Start/ Button Start
12V Power Outlets
Air Purifier
Electronic Parking Brake
Air Conditioner
Yes (Manual)
Yes (Automatic Climate Control)
Parking Assist
Steering Adjustment
Tilt
Anti-glare Mirrors
Manual - Internal Only
| Child Safety Lock | ||||
| Speed Sensing Door Lock | ||||
| Central Locking | Keyless | With Key | ||
| Engine Immobiliser |
Child Safety Lock
Speed Sensing Door Lock
Central Locking
Keyless
With Key
Engine Immobiliser
| Anti-Lock Braking System (ABS) | ||||
| Hill Hold Control | ||||
| Traction Control System (TC/TCS) | ||||
| Brake Assist (BA) | ||||
| Electronic Brake-force Distribution (EBD) | ||||
| Electronic Stability Program (ESP) |
Anti-Lock Braking System (ABS)
Hill Hold Control
Traction Control System (TC/TCS)
Brake Assist (BA)
Electronic Brake-force Distribution (EBD)
Electronic Stability Program (ESP)
| Overspeed Warning | 1 beep over 80kmph | 1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph | ||
| Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS) | ||||
| Emergency Brake Light Flashing | ||||
| Airbags | 2 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger) | 6 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger, 2 Curtain, Driver Side, Front Passenger Side) | ||
| Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB) | ||||
| Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt | ||||
| NCAP Rating | Not Tested | 5 Star (Bharat NCAP) | ||
| Dashcam | ||||
| Seat Belt Warning | ||||
| High-beam Assist | ||||
| Forward Collision Warning (FCW) | ||||
| Child Seat Anchor Points | ||||
| Blind Spot Detection |
Overspeed Warning
1 beep over 80kmph
1 beep over 80kmph, Continuous beeps over 120kmph
Tyre Pressure Monitoring System (TPMS)
Emergency Brake Light Flashing
Airbags
2 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger)
6 Airbags (Driver, Front Passenger, 2 Curtain, Driver Side, Front Passenger Side)
Automatic Emergency Braking (AEB)
Rear Middle Three Point seatbelt
NCAP Rating
Not Tested
5 Star (Bharat NCAP)
Dashcam
Seat Belt Warning
High-beam Assist
Forward Collision Warning (FCW)
Child Seat Anchor Points
Blind Spot Detection
Comet Ev Comparison with similar cars
vs
vs
vs
vs
vs
Punch Ev Comparison with similar cars
vs
vs
vs
vs
Pros And Cons
MG Comet EV
- An affordable and zero-emission electric car that focuses on personal mobility.
- Funky design and modern interiors with adequate feel-good features.
- Easy to drive in crowded cities with ultra-compact size, light steering and small turning radiusWell-built hatchback that doesn’t feel cheap.
- Tech-savvy cabin that has a 10.25-inch touchscreen with wireless Android Auto and Apple CarPlay, connected car benefits, digital key sharing, etc.
- Plenty of customization options and accessories to make your car truly unique.
Tata Punch EV
- New connected LED digital DRLs in the front looks futuristic.
- 360 degree camera with rear blind view monitor helps a lot.
- Electric parking brake with auto hold is a big plus.
- The frunk can be used to store portable charger or other small things.
- 10.25 inch infotainment touchscreen is smooth & fluent to use.
- 10.25 inch drivers display looks cool, can also be customized.
- Front ventilated seats adds to the comfort.
Latest Cars Videos
- Tata Curvv Pure+ S : The Best Value for Money or a Missed Opportunity ? | Detailed Walkaround !
- MG Hector After 35,000 KM: Is It Still the Best SUV After 5 Years in India?
- MG GLOSTER DESERTSTORM & SNOWSTORM FIRST LOOK
- WARNING 💣 ये Diesel Engine ही BOMB है - Tata NEXON Diesel Detailed Drive Review 🔥
- This SUV will shock you 🔥 MG Hector Review after 5500 Kms 🔥 Mileage, Drive, Suspension-PROS & CONS
- MG Astor 2024 - Its Base variant is just 9.98 Lakhs 🔥 5 Star Safety - Tata Curvv Rival
Subscribe to Carbike360 Youtube channel 
Cars Related News And Expert Reviews
Tata Motors Revives Free Charging Offer for Nexon EV and Curvv EV Buyers
Read more...
Tata EV December Discounts: Save Big on Tiago.ev & Punch.ev
Read more...
Top 10 SUV Models and Their Sales in November 2024 in India
Read more...
Tata is offering Discounts on their cars upto Rs. 3.70 lakhs in December 2024
Read more...
India’s Electric Passenger Vehicle Market Sales Report – November 2024
Read more...
JSW MG Motor India Sales Report of November 2024
Read more...